Matt > Great catch with the Eye. It's so obvious once you point it out! And good observations about Coldstone's design. I'll admit that the nature of his makeup completely eluded me initially. Demona's line about "cold stone brought to life" should have been the clue-in, but I guess I took it more...metaphorically? I dunno. It was only when "Legion" explicitly explained it that I had my "oh...huh" moment. And was still kind of confused because he really just looks like flesh-and-blood 10th-century Othello with cyborg parts. Awesome character design, but not so successful at selling the premise.
Craig
posted @ Wed, Nov 26, 2025 11:00:04 am EST from 69.118.30.106

Spotted something interesting when doing another read of Demona #4 last night: The real Eye of Odin has a golden "tail" that trails off to the right, while the the fake one trails off to the left. You can see exactly when Demona made the switch because the "tail" switches between two panels. Another way of looking at this is that the real Eye is Odin's right, but the fake one appears to be Odin's left eye. Demona and her Antioch smith did a decent job with the forgery, but didn't pay attention to this detail. Neither did most of us, it seems. But I'm glad Frank and/or Greg did! I wonder if there are any implications to the fake Eye being the left one. I know there is symbolism with the right hand being trusted and true and the left hand being sinister and untrustworthy.

OnTheUp&Up2Semantics> I like the name Archangel (and Greg has hinted that another of "The Eggs" may bear that name, but I think Angela is perfect for the character and offers a great contrast to Demona. I'm not sure how Archangel offers a better contrast, to be honest.

Likewise, I don't really understand your issues with Brooksbro or Gabriel's coloring. Could they have had a different coloring? Sure, but they don't. And I think that is okay. As a very general rule, gargoyles (and beasts) physically look like their same sex parent with the coloring of their opposite sex parent. But that is only a rough guideline and we have nearly as many exceptions to that rule as we have examples of it. And I think that is good. Otherwise, two biological brothers or two biological sisters would be identical and that's no good (and not very visually interesting). If Gabriel had been designed with Desdemona's coloring, I would've been fine with it, but he didn't. He got Othello's coloring (though with a bit more of Des's earth tone). He still got his mother's blond hair. I think he looks great and his parentage is fairly clear. If he had been a copy of Othello with Desdemona's coloring, I'm not sure that would've been very good. Angela, more or less, showed us that theme. It would've been redundant with Gabriel. Better to give him a bit of a mix. And if Brookbro had Brooklyn's coloring, they would've looked too similar, in my opinion. As it is, it's clear they are brothers without being copies. Same goes for Lefty and Demona or Hyppolyta, Broadway, and True.

I've never visited the "Fandom!Gargoyles Wiki", so I can't speak for their theories. I base my thoughts on canon, canon-in-training, and my own musings. If you are looking more for thoughts on gargoyle biology based on canon and CIT, I suggest using this site and the GargWiki as a guide.

I will agree with you on Coldstone's design. He is stone, but because the stone coloration isn't too dissimilar from Othello's coloration, we kind of lose that idea visually. The fact that his eye and hair are not stone (for some reasons) does not help matters. If Coldstone had a stone eye and hair and Othello had been some very different color (like orange or whatever), I think the "cold stone brought to life" would've been more clear (and he would've looked more monstrous not unlike the ghost gargoyles in "Shadows of the Past").
I also wish it was more clear that he was made of three different gargoyles, but I know there was not time to design those characters at the time.
Matt
"My daughter?! How dare you mock me! I have no daughter." - Demona, 1996
posted @ Wed, Nov 26, 2025 9:36:36 am EST from 69.229.197.48

this is a very nice content that you have written here, keep up the good work!
commercial fencing central coast - [a at gmail dot com]
412641
posted @ Wed, Nov 26, 2025 5:15:00 am EST from 152.32.100.60

https://cardapp1e.isweb.co.kr/
https://cardapp1e.isweb.co.kr/ - [rudolfc at naver dot com]
posted @ Wed, Nov 26, 2025 2:26:26 am EST from 14.39.130.59

https://cardapp1e.isweb.co.kr/
ì¹´ë"œê¹¡ - [rudolfc at naver dot com]
posted @ Wed, Nov 26, 2025 2:25:50 am EST from 14.39.130.59

*Stone-like skin

…c’mon autocorrect. Of all the times you change it preemptively, you didn’t catch that?
OnTheUp&Up2Semantics
posted @ Tue, Nov 25, 2025 5:58:14 pm EST from 70.173.68.31

*Like a character’s name and small details

You write it, you proofread for any mistakes or a better way you could’ve worded it, you reread it, you preview it, triple reread it, post it, and you still find a typo despite everything… why, man? Why?
OnTheUp&Up2Semantics
posted @ Tue, Nov 25, 2025 5:42:00 pm EST from 70.173.68.31

Well it’s almost time to say and give thanks... why not say the opposite to shake it out of the system until it’s time? Anyone else have little gripes about a medium that you know won’t ever be changed retconned but will stick kick a little fuss over it? For me it’s things like a character’s name small details. For example, I wish Trunks from Dragon Ball was named “Boxers” - it still fits his family’s naming convention but also can be a subtle nod to the warrior’s lifestyle of his Saiyan heritage (even though there aren’t any alternative spellings of a vegetable that could be a language pun regarding undergarments... at least to where I’ve looked about in)

To steer it back to Gargoyles, one bit I kick up on is Angela’s name. I kinda want her name to be Archangel to contrast Demona/Angel and Angelika. Another would be changing Brooksbro to have a more reddish coloration and Gabriel to have a tanned coloration to give an extra visual hint on their blood relation to Brooklyn and Desdemona/Coldfire respectively as per according to section of how Gargoyle genetic inheritance is speculated to work on the Gargoyles pages of the Fandom!Gargoyles Wiki. Yeah, maybe it might’ve come from a grandparent or maybe it turns out Gargoyles have an extra chromosome allegedly like what Koi/Goldfish have to encourage a spontaneous mutation every off Rookery Generation to spicen up the Clan genepool yadda yadda etc. etc.

One more example from me would be the “fleshy” bits of Coldstone/Othello actually looking more rock-like because when I learned that it was actually the sone-like skin that covers a Gargoyle when in stone sleep, it kinda threw me for a loop.

Good to get that out of my system. What are your guys? Last calls before Thanksgiving!
OnTheUp&Up2Semantics
posted @ Tue, Nov 25, 2025 5:38:54 pm EST from 70.173.68.31

its such a nice community here.
fence builders blue mountains - [a at gmail dot com]
412641
posted @ Tue, Nov 25, 2025 3:00:29 am EST from 152.32.100.60

card cash info gere !
https://pay.clickn.co.kr/ - [rudolfc at naver dot com]
posted @ Tue, Nov 25, 2025 12:41:41 am EST from 14.39.130.59

There is one "yes" thing for this week - Thanksgiving, which has now become one of the very few holidays to feature in "Gargoyles". I've thought of rereading the last two issues of "Gargoyles Quest" on Thursday (alongside a few other things on Thanksgiving I like to read that day), and wonder how many others here might feel like doing that. (Just as I reread the Double Date story and the Halloween Special from Dynamite on Halloween, a few weeks ago - along with, among other things, a few Carl Barks Donald Duck stories set on Halloween.)
Todd Jensen
posted @ Mon, Nov 24, 2025 8:47:01 pm EST from 68.99.93.213

Third!

It's nice when there's a gap in the schedule that it can be measured in weeks and not months or years.
Phil
posted @ Mon, Nov 24, 2025 10:43:20 am EST from 50.192.123.171

No bots in the countdown.
No new stories this week.
No First!

Second!
Matt
"My daughter?! How dare you mock me! I have no daughter." - Demona, 1996
posted @ Mon, Nov 24, 2025 9:52:21 am EST from 204.184.178.1

First. And a happy Thanksgiving week ahead.

No sun - no moon!
No morn - no noon -
No dawn - no dusk - no proper time of day -
No sky - no earthly view -
No distance looking blue -
No road - no street - no 't'otherside the way' -
No end to any Row -
No indications where the crescents go -
No top to any steeple -
No recognitions of familiar people -
No courtesies for showing 'em -
No knowing 'em!
No travelling at all - no locomotion,
No inkling of the way - no notion -
'No go' - by land or ocean -
No mail - no post -
No news from any foreign coast -
No Park - no Ring - no afternoon gentility -
No company - no nobility -
No warmth, no cheerfulness, no healthful ease,
No comfortable feel in any member -
No shade, no shine,, no butterflies, no bees,
No fruits, no flowers, no leaves, no birds, -
November!

"No", Thomas Hood
Todd Jensen
posted @ Mon, Nov 24, 2025 7:37:20 am EST from 68.99.93.213